{ "buckling": { "basis": "Buckling stability at wind x1.3: PASS for the accepted sampled ideal-geometry path. Both retained meshes passed seven equilibrium/full-tangent checks up to x1.5 wind; endpoint displacement difference 0.59%. The exact assessment-load endpoint is also checked. No additional meshes are required for this scope. This is not an ultimate buckling factor or a guarantee between sampled states or for untested imperfections.", "status": "PASS" }, "buckling_analysis": { "cases": [ { "first_positive_factor": 5.648134, "mesh_label": "h090", "mode_count": 20, "positive_factors": [ 5.648134, 7.427389, 7.629377, 7.734444, 7.935678, 8.407735, 8.510226, 8.820192, 8.933925, 9.474543, 10.2969, 10.33873, 10.73579, 11.17873, 12.18929, 12.36697, 12.43655, 12.59747, 12.61068, 12.7001 ] }, { "first_positive_factor": 5.60366, "mesh_label": "h060", "mode_count": 20, "positive_factors": [ 5.60366, 7.579126, 7.677224, 7.878426, 8.345031, 8.588126, 8.739886, 8.756706, 8.913767, 9.604478, 10.22816, 10.27223, 10.68266, 11.12184, 11.28902, 12.11809, 12.41866, 12.52534, 12.55955, 12.62851 ] }, { "first_positive_factor": 5.583233, "mesh_label": "h050", "mode_count": 20, "positive_factors": [ 5.583233, 6.968834, 7.654767, 7.856725, 8.310312, 8.651947, 8.715508, 8.897199, 10.06401, 10.11897, 10.19091, 10.23079, 10.65103, 11.06828, 11.55073, 12.05847, 12.30896, 12.3857, 12.46757, 12.58324 ] } ], "convergence": { "comparison_mesh": "h050", "factor_relative_tolerance": 0.05, "first_comparison_mode_match": { "comparison_factor": 5.583233, "comparison_mode": 1, "factor_relative_change": 0.003645296110042321, "modal_assurance": 0.9999902710584215, "reference_factor": 5.60366, "reference_mode": 1 }, "first_reference_mode_match": { "comparison_factor": 5.583233, "comparison_mode": 1, "factor_relative_change": 0.003645296110042321, "modal_assurance": 0.9999902710584215, "reference_factor": 5.60366, "reference_mode": 1 }, "matches": [ { "comparison_factor": 5.583233, "comparison_mode": 1, "factor_relative_change": 0.003645296110042321, "modal_assurance": 0.9999902710584215, "reference_factor": 5.60366, "reference_mode": 1 }, { "comparison_factor": 6.968834, "comparison_mode": 2, "factor_relative_change": 0.080522741012618, "modal_assurance": 0.9650877220808225, "reference_factor": 7.579126, "reference_mode": 2 }, { "comparison_factor": 7.654767, "comparison_mode": 3, "factor_relative_change": 0.0029251458600140067, "modal_assurance": 0.9997195858479423, "reference_factor": 7.677224, "reference_mode": 3 }, { "comparison_factor": 7.856725, "comparison_mode": 4, "factor_relative_change": 0.002754484207886219, "modal_assurance": 0.9987632554347388, "reference_factor": 7.878426, "reference_mode": 4 }, { "comparison_factor": 8.310312, "comparison_mode": 5, "factor_relative_change": 0.004160439907293434, "modal_assurance": 0.9991544872468732, "reference_factor": 8.345031, "reference_mode": 5 }, { "comparison_factor": 10.06401, "comparison_mode": 9, "factor_relative_change": 0.14664969530038213, "modal_assurance": 0.9773679226006436, "reference_factor": 8.588126, "reference_mode": 6 }, { "comparison_factor": 8.651947, "comparison_mode": 6, "factor_relative_change": 0.010061801721441267, "modal_assurance": 0.9625442520752039, "reference_factor": 8.739886, "reference_mode": 7 }, { "comparison_factor": 8.715508, "comparison_mode": 7, "factor_relative_change": 0.004704737146593665, "modal_assurance": 0.9993887559682705, "reference_factor": 8.756706, "reference_mode": 8 }, { "comparison_factor": 8.897199, "comparison_mode": 8, "factor_relative_change": 0.001858697899552397, "modal_assurance": 0.9999984505483616, "reference_factor": 8.913767, "reference_mode": 9 }, { "comparison_factor": 10.11897, "comparison_mode": 10, "factor_relative_change": 0.050844305299847604, "modal_assurance": 0.5871311146746072, "reference_factor": 9.604478, "reference_mode": 10 }, { "comparison_factor": 10.19091, "comparison_mode": 11, "factor_relative_change": 0.003641906266620802, "modal_assurance": 0.999286806688791, "reference_factor": 10.22816, "reference_mode": 11 }, { "comparison_factor": 10.23079, "comparison_mode": 12, "factor_relative_change": 0.004034177583640524, "modal_assurance": 0.9998911025833223, "reference_factor": 10.27223, "reference_mode": 12 }, { "comparison_factor": 10.65103, "comparison_mode": 13, "factor_relative_change": 0.002960873040984158, "modal_assurance": 0.9997282944587194, "reference_factor": 10.68266, "reference_mode": 13 }, { "comparison_factor": 11.06828, "comparison_mode": 14, "factor_relative_change": 0.004815749911885168, "modal_assurance": 0.9999393607372128, "reference_factor": 11.12184, "reference_mode": 14 }, { "comparison_factor": 11.55073, "comparison_mode": 15, "factor_relative_change": 0.02265744243004546, "modal_assurance": 0.3047067795257871, "reference_factor": 11.28902, "reference_mode": 15 }, { "comparison_factor": 12.05847, "comparison_mode": 16, "factor_relative_change": 0.004919917247685128, "modal_assurance": 0.9999277902605126, "reference_factor": 12.11809, "reference_mode": 16 }, { "comparison_factor": 12.3857, "comparison_mode": 18, "factor_relative_change": 0.002654070568000027, "modal_assurance": 0.9943796642868703, "reference_factor": 12.41866, "reference_mode": 17 }, { "comparison_factor": 12.46757, "comparison_mode": 19, "factor_relative_change": 0.004612250046705292, "modal_assurance": 0.9960181596043982, "reference_factor": 12.52534, "reference_mode": 18 }, { "comparison_factor": 12.30896, "comparison_mode": 17, "factor_relative_change": 0.019952147967084728, "modal_assurance": 5.622224925832e-05, "reference_factor": 12.55955, "reference_mode": 19 }, { "comparison_factor": 12.58324, "comparison_mode": 20, "factor_relative_change": 0.0035847459438999823, "modal_assurance": 0.998720728023729, "reference_factor": 12.62851, "reference_mode": 20 } ], "minimum_modal_assurance": 0.7, "reference_mesh": "h060", "status": "PASS" }, "fine_mesh_repetitions": [ { "accepted_increments": 10, "amplitude_mm": null, "case_slug": "plate_bending__supzlt200mm__wind_buckling__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__repeat01", "cutbacks": 0, "detail": "Retained native evidence; no load clipping.", "elapsed_seconds": 801.2974800829543, "equilibrium_status": null, "first_factor": 5.583233, "input_sha256": "16562cab18bbb018f0e3cf6444638623c768e5da332d8b0d6636b9c340c1ace5", "iteration_history_sha256": "eb244166f967b356b7e1e7674c222210a4c960894b24f1f42ea0be16edc8c54d", "maximum_component_utilization": null, "maximum_connector_force_n": null, "maximum_displacement_mm": null, "maximum_newton_iterations": 3, "mesh_input_sha256": "dcaa2efb957d69a6003083df54a953c70d56a2f8165f0c2f6fe549315fb3aa2a", "mesh_label": "h050", "native_run_sha256": "a574eba47e394033af4a88a54c40dbfe4a55e0020e09b986d89d5e9b8b7d7e0a", "solver_executable_sha256": "2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d", "source_sha256": "be401f3e39e987e51d2f79220cc7ca116e982b68d5668fcf36d13fa4b2ae7eb8", "status": "PASS", "total_newton_iterations": 30, "wind_input_sha256": "16e7ac43eb44e1a286bf59f9c23e49ffdb947ad476c91121e6b6cf7fa35fb684" }, { "accepted_increments": 10, "amplitude_mm": null, "case_slug": "plate_bending__supzlt200mm__wind_buckling__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__repeat02", "cutbacks": 0, "detail": "Retained native evidence; no load clipping.", "elapsed_seconds": 799.9288796669571, "equilibrium_status": null, "first_factor": 5.583233, "input_sha256": "16562cab18bbb018f0e3cf6444638623c768e5da332d8b0d6636b9c340c1ace5", "iteration_history_sha256": "eb244166f967b356b7e1e7674c222210a4c960894b24f1f42ea0be16edc8c54d", "maximum_component_utilization": null, "maximum_connector_force_n": null, "maximum_displacement_mm": null, "maximum_newton_iterations": 3, "mesh_input_sha256": "dcaa2efb957d69a6003083df54a953c70d56a2f8165f0c2f6fe549315fb3aa2a", "mesh_label": "h050", "native_run_sha256": "bfcec31a4a766734212a7c81e9142a265b3fa77e4b447320152946d65029fe2c", "solver_executable_sha256": "2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d", "source_sha256": "2a5db1108c84b5aa897b96be36ef4312d1c268caa23393511bf9b714bf316d91", "status": "PASS", "total_newton_iterations": 30, "wind_input_sha256": "16e7ac43eb44e1a286bf59f9c23e49ffdb947ad476c91121e6b6cf7fa35fb684" } ], "first_factor_relative_to_source_cfd": 8.3748495, "imperfection_coverage_status": "INDETERMINATE", "interpretation": "Eigenbuckling exceeds the assessed load; required service-load imperfections or baseline numerical gates are incomplete. Loaded-stiffness qualification failed: the rigid-coupling pendulum test misses a known negative stiffness direction; ordinary exports also lose active connector equations. Positive matrix counts and repeatable eigenfactors therefore do not establish a buckling margin.", "production_factor_relative_spread": 0.0, "production_repeatability_status": "PASS", "service_cases": [ { "accepted_increments": null, "amplitude_mm": 1.2, "case_slug": "plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_pos001200um", "cutbacks": null, "detail": "required artifact is missing: /Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_pos001200um/case.json", "elapsed_seconds": null, "equilibrium_status": null, "first_factor": null, "input_sha256": null, "iteration_history_sha256": null, "maximum_component_utilization": null, "maximum_connector_force_n": null, "maximum_displacement_mm": null, "maximum_newton_iterations": null, "mesh_input_sha256": null, "mesh_label": "h050", "native_run_sha256": null, "solver_executable_sha256": null, "source_sha256": null, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "total_newton_iterations": null, "wind_input_sha256": null }, { "accepted_increments": null, "amplitude_mm": -1.2, "case_slug": "plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_neg001200um", "cutbacks": null, "detail": "required artifact is missing: /Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_neg001200um/case.json", "elapsed_seconds": null, "equilibrium_status": null, "first_factor": null, "input_sha256": null, "iteration_history_sha256": null, "maximum_component_utilization": null, "maximum_connector_force_n": null, "maximum_displacement_mm": null, "maximum_newton_iterations": null, "mesh_input_sha256": null, "mesh_label": "h050", "native_run_sha256": null, "solver_executable_sha256": null, "source_sha256": null, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "total_newton_iterations": null, "wind_input_sha256": null }, { "accepted_increments": null, "amplitude_mm": 6.0, "case_slug": "plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_pos006000um", "cutbacks": null, "detail": "required artifact is missing: /Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_pos006000um/case.json", "elapsed_seconds": null, "equilibrium_status": null, "first_factor": null, "input_sha256": null, "iteration_history_sha256": null, "maximum_component_utilization": null, "maximum_connector_force_n": null, "maximum_displacement_mm": null, "maximum_newton_iterations": null, "mesh_input_sha256": null, "mesh_label": "h050", "native_run_sha256": null, "solver_executable_sha256": null, "source_sha256": null, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "total_newton_iterations": null, "wind_input_sha256": null }, { "accepted_increments": null, "amplitude_mm": -6.0, "case_slug": "plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_neg006000um", "cutbacks": null, "detail": "required artifact is missing: /Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_neg006000um/case.json", "elapsed_seconds": null, "equilibrium_status": null, "first_factor": null, "input_sha256": null, "iteration_history_sha256": null, "maximum_component_utilization": null, "maximum_connector_force_n": null, "maximum_displacement_mm": null, "maximum_newton_iterations": null, "mesh_input_sha256": null, "mesh_label": "h050", "native_run_sha256": null, "solver_executable_sha256": null, "source_sha256": null, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "total_newton_iterations": null, "wind_input_sha256": null } ], "service_imperfection_status": "INDETERMINATE", "solver_executable_sha256": "2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d", "status": "INDETERMINATE", "tangent_stiffness_status": "INDETERMINATE" }, "configuration_sha256": "f7c4bf1001d755c506b12781fc8359b6cdab3ebb7a4c39005db58c9b449aeb90", "connector_loads": { "connector_count": 420, "force_maximum_connector_id": "TV57UI", "force_maximum_n": 833.5590100541503, "force_maximum_side": "far", "force_mean_n": 145.00672298587892, "force_std_dev_n": 174.75228229902413, "grounded_connector_count": 57, "moment_maximum_connector_id": "TV5nUI", "moment_maximum_nm": 95.96073961227596, "moment_maximum_side": "near", "moment_mean_nm": 12.190658719103903, "moment_std_dev_nm": 14.999230597089094 }, "deformation": "reported; criterion not supplied", "directional_utilization": [ { "maximum": 0.6717126315789473, "name": "membrane_1", "p95": 0.019467721518987343, "p99": 0.04661736842105263, "p99_9": 0.10217926315789473 }, { "maximum": 0.640794382022472, "name": "membrane_2", "p95": 0.015223033707865168, "p99": 0.035907752808988766, "p99_9": 0.08227702247191011 }, { "maximum": 0.756131067961165, "name": "bending_1", "p95": 0.07671407766990292, "p99": 0.16879490291262136, "p99_9": 0.32197087378640776 }, { "maximum": 0.689566917293233, "name": "bending_2", "p95": 0.07305484962406016, "p99": 0.16551353383458647, "p99_9": 0.32526729323308273 }, { "maximum": 0.68914, "name": "panel_shear_12", "p95": 0.08246685714285715, "p99": 0.17541114285714285, "p99_9": 0.3186232228571443 }, { "maximum": 0.846565, "name": "rolling_shear_23", "p95": 0.04634925, "p99": 0.114577375, "p99_9": 0.2519798212500059 }, { "maximum": 1.11023, "name": "planar_shear_31", "p95": 0.048742, "p99": 0.122872, "p99_9": 0.257825 }, { "maximum": 1.11023, "name": "maximum_individual", "p95": 0.13215864661654136, "p99": 0.2412398357142835, "p99_9": 0.41475922330097087 } ], "linear_peak_diagnostics": [ { "adjacent_relative_changes": [ 0.13944030308607902, 0.12078551761639926 ], "at_fine_hotspot": { "detail": "Same component, face and coordinate; S6 interpolation of signed nodal stresses. This is not an integration-point or through-thickness shear qualification.", "fine_ratio": 0.6717126315789438, "relative_change": 0.12078551761639576, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "transition_ratio": 0.5905794736842097 }, "at_transition_hotspot": { "detail": "Same component, face and coordinate; S6 interpolation of signed nodal stresses. This is not an integration-point or through-thickness shear qualification.", "fine_ratio": 0.6717126315789438, "relative_change": 0.12078551761639576, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "transition_ratio": 0.5905794736842097 }, "fine_peak": 0.6717126315789473, "history": [ { "component_id": "C026", "element_tag": 15767, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h090", "node_tag": 26696, "position_m": [ -2.274, 0.4131790008544922, 3.197740234375 ], "ratio": 0.6862736842105264, "source_result_sha256": "631163f115ed35ce9a401edfa490bb096af288edec91cf455465412d85c154c4", "target_size_m": 0.09 }, { "component_id": "C026", "element_tag": 23002, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h060", "node_tag": 28426, "position_m": [ -2.274, 0.4131790008544922, 3.197740234375 ], "ratio": 0.5905794736842105, "source_result_sha256": "3764f8040c4b0526d6efc7d14a7357e8e10e99b3ea9af47b4ddca33e7e76eadd", "target_size_m": 0.06 }, { "component_id": "C026", "element_tag": 32398, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h050", "node_tag": 30650, "position_m": [ -2.274, 0.4131790008544922, 3.197740234375 ], "ratio": 0.6717126315789473, "source_result_sha256": "eb1bec74f7116211f73a6578be771f2bdff299a5766652a01a6a2f8a679c9c0f", "target_size_m": 0.05 } ], "hotspot_field_status": "INDETERMINATE", "magnitude_trend": "non-monotonic", "name": "membrane_1", "peak_location_distance_m": 0.0, "relative_change": 0.12078551761639926, "same_component": true, "same_face": true, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "transition_peak": 0.5905794736842105 }, { "adjacent_relative_changes": [ 0.003585783267453687, 0.20928990876843526 ], "at_fine_hotspot": { "detail": "Same component, face and coordinate; S6 interpolation of signed nodal stresses. This is not an integration-point or through-thickness shear qualification.", "fine_ratio": 0.640794382022472, "relative_change": 0.4051765101953861, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "transition_ratio": 0.38115955056179773 }, "at_transition_hotspot": { "detail": "Same component, face and coordinate; S6 interpolation of signed nodal stresses. This is not an integration-point or through-thickness shear qualification.", "fine_ratio": 0.5134741573033708, "relative_change": 0.013226708563825955, "status": "PASS", "transition_ratio": 0.506682584269663 }, "fine_peak": 0.640794382022472, "history": [ { "component_id": "C014", "element_tag": 5444, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h090", "node_tag": 1292, "position_m": [ -2.9939999999999998, 0.9213125, 0.5526139526367188 ], "ratio": 0.5048657303370786, "source_result_sha256": "631163f115ed35ce9a401edfa490bb096af288edec91cf455465412d85c154c4", "target_size_m": 0.09 }, { "component_id": "C014", "element_tag": 9783, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h060", "node_tag": 1292, "position_m": [ -2.9939999999999998, 0.9213125, 0.5526139526367188 ], "ratio": 0.506682584269663, "source_result_sha256": "3764f8040c4b0526d6efc7d14a7357e8e10e99b3ea9af47b4ddca33e7e76eadd", "target_size_m": 0.06 }, { "component_id": "C028", "element_tag": 35660, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h050", "node_tag": 31999, "position_m": [ -2.154, 0.47739385986328126, 3.2704554443359375 ], "ratio": 0.640794382022472, "source_result_sha256": "eb1bec74f7116211f73a6578be771f2bdff299a5766652a01a6a2f8a679c9c0f", "target_size_m": 0.05 } ], "hotspot_field_status": "INDETERMINATE", "magnitude_trend": "increasing", "name": "membrane_2", "peak_location_distance_m": 2.8791189855687915, "relative_change": 0.20928990876843526, "same_component": false, "same_face": true, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "transition_peak": 0.506682584269663 }, { "adjacent_relative_changes": [ 0.014798316380217568, 0.0848275906344895 ], "at_fine_hotspot": { "detail": "Same component, face and coordinate; S6 interpolation of signed nodal stresses. This is not an integration-point or through-thickness shear qualification.", "fine_ratio": 0.756131067961165, "relative_change": 0.09951157991450008, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "transition_ratio": 0.6808872707659113 }, "at_transition_hotspot": { "detail": "Same component, face and coordinate; S6 interpolation of signed nodal stresses. This is not an integration-point or through-thickness shear qualification.", "fine_ratio": 0.7462562196601938, "relative_change": 0.07271755593912203, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "transition_ratio": 0.691990291262136 }, "fine_peak": 0.756131067961165, "history": [ { "component_id": "C032", "element_tag": 19623, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h090", "node_tag": 28711, "position_m": [ -1.9140000000000001, 0.4151793029864662, 0.7562784294228583 ], "ratio": 0.68175, "source_result_sha256": "631163f115ed35ce9a401edfa490bb096af288edec91cf455465412d85c154c4", "target_size_m": 0.09 }, { "component_id": "C032", "element_tag": 28403, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h060", "node_tag": 30975, "position_m": [ -1.9140000000000001, 0.4151793029864663, 0.7562784294228583 ], "ratio": 0.691990291262136, "source_result_sha256": "3764f8040c4b0526d6efc7d14a7357e8e10e99b3ea9af47b4ddca33e7e76eadd", "target_size_m": 0.06 }, { "component_id": "C032", "element_tag": 40048, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h050", "node_tag": 34018, "position_m": [ -1.9140000000000001, 0.4064752839259153, 0.7562784294228583 ], "ratio": 0.756131067961165, "source_result_sha256": "eb1bec74f7116211f73a6578be771f2bdff299a5766652a01a6a2f8a679c9c0f", "target_size_m": 0.05 } ], "hotspot_field_status": "INDETERMINATE", "magnitude_trend": "increasing", "name": "bending_1", "peak_location_distance_m": 0.008704019060551016, "relative_change": 0.0848275906344895, "same_component": true, "same_face": true, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "transition_peak": 0.691990291262136 }, { "adjacent_relative_changes": [ 0.030373091151257713, 0.045462227572280245 ], "at_fine_hotspot": { "detail": "Same component, face and coordinate; S6 interpolation of signed nodal stresses. This is not an integration-point or through-thickness shear qualification.", "fine_ratio": 0.689566917293233, "relative_change": 0.045462227572280245, "status": "PASS", "transition_ratio": 0.6582176691729323 }, "at_transition_hotspot": { "detail": "Same component, face and coordinate; S6 interpolation of signed nodal stresses. This is not an integration-point or through-thickness shear qualification.", "fine_ratio": 0.689566917293233, "relative_change": 0.045462227572280245, "status": "PASS", "transition_ratio": 0.6582176691729323 }, "fine_peak": 0.689566917293233, "history": [ { "component_id": "C032", "element_tag": 19573, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h090", "node_tag": 5923, "position_m": [ -1.9140000000000001, 0.536044337272644, 0.47072576689720147 ], "ratio": 0.6382255639097745, "source_result_sha256": "631163f115ed35ce9a401edfa490bb096af288edec91cf455465412d85c154c4", "target_size_m": 0.09 }, { "component_id": "C032", "element_tag": 28348, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h060", "node_tag": 5923, "position_m": [ -1.9140000000000001, 0.536044337272644, 0.47072576689720147 ], "ratio": 0.6582176691729323, "source_result_sha256": "3764f8040c4b0526d6efc7d14a7357e8e10e99b3ea9af47b4ddca33e7e76eadd", "target_size_m": 0.06 }, { "component_id": "C032", "element_tag": 39981, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h050", "node_tag": 5923, "position_m": [ -1.9140000000000001, 0.536044337272644, 0.47072576689720147 ], "ratio": 0.689566917293233, "source_result_sha256": "eb1bec74f7116211f73a6578be771f2bdff299a5766652a01a6a2f8a679c9c0f", "target_size_m": 0.05 } ], "hotspot_field_status": "PASS", "magnitude_trend": "increasing", "name": "bending_2", "peak_location_distance_m": 0.0, "relative_change": 0.045462227572280245, "same_component": true, "same_face": true, "status": "PASS", "transition_peak": 0.6582176691729323 }, { "adjacent_relative_changes": [ 0.05453092522772585, 0.0778071219200743 ], "at_fine_hotspot": { "detail": "Same component, face and coordinate; S6 interpolation of signed nodal stresses. This is not an integration-point or through-thickness shear qualification.", "fine_ratio": 0.68914, "relative_change": 0.08751280063350173, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "transition_ratio": 0.6288314285714286 }, "at_transition_hotspot": { "detail": "Same component, face and coordinate; S6 interpolation of signed nodal stresses. This is not an integration-point or through-thickness shear qualification.", "fine_ratio": 0.6758657142857143, "relative_change": 0.059694867534971066, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "transition_ratio": 0.63552 }, "fine_peak": 0.68914, "history": [ { "component_id": "C034", "element_tag": 21428, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h090", "node_tag": 29411, "position_m": [ -1.794, 0.32944002938580064, 1.0782989556006664 ], "ratio": 0.6721742857142857, "source_result_sha256": "631163f115ed35ce9a401edfa490bb096af288edec91cf455465412d85c154c4", "target_size_m": 0.09 }, { "component_id": "C032", "element_tag": 28598, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h060", "node_tag": 30976, "position_m": [ -1.9140000000000001, 0.44273811782820016, 0.7508039485981479 ], "ratio": 0.63552, "source_result_sha256": "3764f8040c4b0526d6efc7d14a7357e8e10e99b3ea9af47b4ddca33e7e76eadd", "target_size_m": 0.06 }, { "component_id": "C032", "element_tag": 40440, "face": "negative", "mesh_label": "h050", "node_tag": 5619, "position_m": [ -1.9140000000000001, 0.4441848754882813, 0.7453294677734376 ], "ratio": 0.68914, "source_result_sha256": "eb1bec74f7116211f73a6578be771f2bdff299a5766652a01a6a2f8a679c9c0f", "target_size_m": 0.05 } ], "hotspot_field_status": "INDETERMINATE", "magnitude_trend": "non-monotonic", "name": "panel_shear_12", "peak_location_distance_m": 0.005662424218223571, "relative_change": 0.0778071219200743, "same_component": true, "same_face": true, "status": "INDETERMINATE", "transition_peak": 0.63552 }, { "adjacent_relative_changes": [ 0.010171259409319297, 0.020397134301559823 ], "at_fine_hotspot": { "detail": "Same component, face and coordinate; S6 interpolation of signed nodal stresses. This is not an integration-point or through-thickness shear qualification.", "fine_ratio": 0.846565, "relative_change": 0.020397134301559823, "status": "PASS", "transition_ratio": 0.8292975 }, "at_transition_hotspot": { "detail": "Same component, face and coordinate; S6 interpolation of signed nodal stresses. This is not an integration-point or through-thickness shear qualification.", "fine_ratio": 0.846565, "relative_change": 0.020397134301559823, "status": "PASS", "transition_ratio": 0.8292975 }, "fine_peak": 0.846565, "history": [ { "component_id": "C022", "element_tag": 11323, "face": "positive", "mesh_label": "h090", "node_tag": 3475, "position_m": [ -2.5140000000000002, 0.5393407313693278, 0.967518648727669 ], "ratio": 0.8208625, "source_result_sha256": "631163f115ed35ce9a401edfa490bb096af288edec91cf455465412d85c154c4", "target_size_m": 0.09 }, { "component_id": "C022", "element_tag": 16673, "face": "positive", "mesh_label": "h060", "node_tag": 3475, "position_m": [ -2.5140000000000002, 0.5393407313693278, 0.967518648727669 ], "ratio": 0.8292975, "source_result_sha256": "3764f8040c4b0526d6efc7d14a7357e8e10e99b3ea9af47b4ddca33e7e76eadd", "target_size_m": 0.06 }, { "component_id": "C022", "element_tag": 23467, "face": "positive", "mesh_label": "h050", "node_tag": 3475, "position_m": [ -2.5140000000000002, 0.5393407313693278, 0.967518648727669 ], "ratio": 0.846565, "source_result_sha256": "eb1bec74f7116211f73a6578be771f2bdff299a5766652a01a6a2f8a679c9c0f", "target_size_m": 0.05 } ], "hotspot_field_status": "PASS", "magnitude_trend": "increasing", "name": "rolling_shear_23", "peak_location_distance_m": 0.0, "relative_change": 0.020397134301559823, "same_component": true, "same_face": true, "status": "PASS", "transition_peak": 0.8292975 }, { "adjacent_relative_changes": [ 0.013981904673071597, 0.034344234978337815 ], "at_fine_hotspot": { "detail": "Same component, face and coordinate; S6 interpolation of signed nodal stresses. This is not an integration-point or through-thickness shear qualification.", "fine_ratio": 1.11023, "relative_change": 0.034344234978337815, "status": "PASS", "transition_ratio": 1.0721 }, "at_transition_hotspot": { "detail": "Same component, face and coordinate; S6 interpolation of signed nodal stresses. This is not an integration-point or through-thickness shear qualification.", "fine_ratio": 1.11023, "relative_change": 0.034344234978337815, "status": "PASS", "transition_ratio": 1.0721 }, "fine_peak": 1.11023, "history": [ { "component_id": "C032", "element_tag": 19623, "face": "positive", "mesh_label": "h090", "node_tag": 29216, "position_m": [ -1.9140000000000001, 0.4371999250791767, 0.771760277943851 ], "ratio": 1.05711, "source_result_sha256": "631163f115ed35ce9a401edfa490bb096af288edec91cf455465412d85c154c4", "target_size_m": 0.09 }, { "component_id": "C032", "element_tag": 28403, "face": "positive", "mesh_label": "h060", "node_tag": 31632, "position_m": [ -1.9140000000000001, 0.4371999250791767, 0.771760277943851 ], "ratio": 1.0721, "source_result_sha256": "3764f8040c4b0526d6efc7d14a7357e8e10e99b3ea9af47b4ddca33e7e76eadd", "target_size_m": 0.06 }, { "component_id": "C032", "element_tag": 40048, "face": "positive", "mesh_label": "h050", "node_tag": 34856, "position_m": [ -1.9140000000000001, 0.4371999250791767, 0.771760277943851 ], "ratio": 1.11023, "source_result_sha256": "eb1bec74f7116211f73a6578be771f2bdff299a5766652a01a6a2f8a679c9c0f", "target_size_m": 0.05 } ], "hotspot_field_status": "PASS", "magnitude_trend": "increasing", "name": "planar_shear_31", "peak_location_distance_m": 0.0, "relative_change": 0.034344234978337815, "same_component": true, "same_face": true, "status": "PASS", "transition_peak": 1.0721 } ], "material_strength": { "basis": "Current h060, wind x1.3: agreed separate panel action checks PASS; maximum ratio 0.989253. Characteristic strengths are unchanged. Numerical endpoint/tangent prerequisites PASS/PASS. No action ratios are summed. This is acceptance of the agreed separate checks, not a full ply-level or combined-load failure assessment; face transverse stresses do not bound interior/core shear.", "status": "PASS" }, "meshes": [ { "below_minimum_edge_instances": 19157, "elements": 64893, "label": "h090", "median_s6_nodal_interval_mm": 26.999999999999915, "minimum_corner_edge_mm": 0.048192728600885665, "nodes": 148689, "status": "PASS", "target_size_mm": 90.0 }, { "below_minimum_edge_instances": 26679, "elements": 92378, "label": "h060", "median_s6_nodal_interval_mm": 22.728734991010004, "minimum_corner_edge_mm": 0.048192728600885665, "nodes": 207578, "status": "PASS", "target_size_mm": 60.0 }, { "below_minimum_edge_instances": 67775, "elements": 130405, "label": "h050", "median_s6_nodal_interval_mm": 18.774116479597218, "minimum_corner_edge_mm": 0.048192728600885665, "nodes": 286497, "status": "PASS", "target_size_mm": 50.0 } ], "missing_or_invalid_evidence": [ "static h090/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear: [Errno 2] No such file or directory: '/Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h090/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear/result.json'", "static h060/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear: [Errno 2] No such file or directory: '/Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h060/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear/result.json'", "static h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear: [Errno 2] No such file or directory: '/Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear/result.json'", "stability h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_pos001200um: required artifact is missing: /Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_pos001200um/case.json", "stability h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_neg001200um: required artifact is missing: /Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_neg001200um/case.json", "stability h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_pos006000um: required artifact is missing: /Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_pos006000um/case.json", "stability h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_neg006000um: required artifact is missing: /Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear__ccx_2b07a575ee54bf7dd83205139c863cf7df0bdbb5f8279fb4f9bdb53b8a62649d__mode01_neg006000um/case.json", "strength assessment: [Errno 2] No such file or directory: '/Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear/result.json'" ], "nonlinear_attempts": [ { "accepted_wind_factor": 1.1578125, "convergence": { "accepted_increments": 23, "completed_steps": 2, "cutback_attempts": 11, "final_step_time": 0.771875, "maximum_iterations": 16, "total_iterations": 280 }, "log_path": "native/solves/h090/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear/analysis.log", "mesh_label": "h090", "messages": [ "*ERROR: too many cutbacks" ], "metadata_path": "native/solves/h090/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear/case.json", "status": "FAIL" }, { "accepted_wind_factor": 1.1695305, "convergence": { "accepted_increments": 24, "completed_steps": 2, "cutback_attempts": 12, "final_step_time": 0.779687, "maximum_iterations": 16, "total_iterations": 309 }, "log_path": "native/solves/h060/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear/analysis.log", "mesh_label": "h060", "messages": [ "*ERROR: too many cutbacks" ], "metadata_path": "native/solves/h060/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear/case.json", "status": "FAIL" }, { "accepted_wind_factor": 1.1859375, "convergence": { "accepted_increments": 23, "completed_steps": 2, "cutback_attempts": 11, "final_step_time": 0.790625, "maximum_iterations": 16, "total_iterations": 278 }, "log_path": "native/solves/h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear/analysis.log", "mesh_label": "h050", "messages": [ "*ERROR: too many cutbacks" ], "metadata_path": "native/solves/h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear/case.json", "status": "FAIL" } ], "numerical_robustness": { "comparisons": [ { "comparison_case": "h060/combined_linear", "comparison_value": 120.62377785002104, "dimension": "linear mesh", "metric": "maximum displacement mm", "reference_case": "h090/combined_linear", "reference_value": 119.92805526918721, "relative_change": 0.005767706775847009, "status": "PASS", "tolerance": 0.05 }, { "comparison_case": "h060/combined_linear", "comparison_value": 0.24262894736842106, "dimension": "linear mesh", "metric": "all-element maximum-individual p99", "reference_case": "h090/combined_linear", "reference_value": 0.24769310535714203, "relative_change": 0.02044529249782349, "status": "PASS", "tolerance": 0.05 }, { "comparison_case": "h060/combined_linear", "comparison_value": 144.94551293981647, "dimension": "linear mesh", "metric": "mean connector force N", "reference_case": "h090/combined_linear", "reference_value": 145.43591922238906, "relative_change": 0.0033719749921111487, "status": "PASS", "tolerance": 0.05 }, { "comparison_case": "h050/combined_linear", "comparison_value": 121.07535282600192, "dimension": "linear mesh", "metric": "maximum displacement mm", "reference_case": "h060/combined_linear", "reference_value": 120.62377785002104, "relative_change": 0.0037297019206694905, "status": "PASS", "tolerance": 0.05 }, { "comparison_case": "h050/combined_linear", "comparison_value": 0.2412398357142835, "dimension": "linear mesh", "metric": "all-element maximum-individual p99", "reference_case": "h060/combined_linear", "reference_value": 0.24262894736842106, "relative_change": 0.005725251126067183, "status": "PASS", "tolerance": 0.05 }, { "comparison_case": "h050/combined_linear", "comparison_value": 145.00672298587892, "dimension": "linear mesh", "metric": "mean connector force N", "reference_case": "h060/combined_linear", "reference_value": 144.94551293981647, "relative_change": 0.00042211867699690604, "status": "PASS", "tolerance": 0.05 } ], "configuration_sha256": "f7c4bf1001d755c506b12781fc8359b6cdab3ebb7a4c39005db58c9b449aeb90", "effective_wind_factor": 1.5, "grain_policy": "The validated seeded station-angle realization is held fixed; grain is not a robustness variable.", "linear_mesh_convergence": { "basis": "All adjacent meshes are reported; the two finest must agree within 5.0% for all three metrics.", "name": "linear mesh", "status": "PASS" }, "material_model": "plate_bending", "mesh_admission": { "basis": "Each adjacent target must reduce measured median S6 nodal spacing by at least 10.0% and increase the element count.", "name": "mesh admission", "status": "PASS" }, "mesh_pairs": [ { "coarse_interval_mm": 26.999999999999915, "coarse_label": "h090", "element_count_growth": 0.4235433713959904, "fine_interval_mm": 22.728734991010004, "fine_label": "h060", "required_spacing_reduction": 0.1, "spacing_reduction": 0.1581950003329602, "status": "PASS" }, { "coarse_interval_mm": 22.728734991010004, "coarse_label": "h060", "element_count_growth": 0.4116456299118838, "fine_interval_mm": 18.774116479597218, "fine_label": "h050", "required_spacing_reduction": 0.1, "spacing_reduction": 0.17399201992442492, "status": "PASS" } ], "meshes": [ { "elements": 64893, "label": "h090", "median_corner_edge_mm": 53.99999999999983, "median_s6_nodal_interval_mm": 26.999999999999915, "minimum_scaled_inverse_condition": 0.0012760696570434137, "nodes": 148689, "target_size_mm": 90.0 }, { "elements": 92378, "label": "h060", "median_corner_edge_mm": 45.45746998202001, "median_s6_nodal_interval_mm": 22.728734991010004, "minimum_scaled_inverse_condition": 0.0025518650533883805, "nodes": 207578, "target_size_mm": 60.0 }, { "elements": 130405, "label": "h050", "median_corner_edge_mm": 37.548232959194436, "median_s6_nodal_interval_mm": 18.774116479597218, "minimum_scaled_inverse_condition": 0.002551865053327499, "nodes": 286497, "target_size_mm": 50.0 } ], "method_fidelity": { "basis": "A linear and nonlinear endpoint is required on every admitted mesh.", "name": "linear approximation fidelity", "status": "INDETERMINATE" }, "method_interpretation": "No baseline method is selected until the nonlinear completion and mesh gates pass.", "missing_or_invalid_evidence": [ "response h090/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear: missing artifact: /Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h090/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear/result.json", "response h060/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear: missing artifact: /Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h060/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear/result.json", "response h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear: missing artifact: /Users/vladimir/Documents/src/projects/cat-strength-calculator/results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/native/solves/h050/plate_bending__supzlt200mm__combined_nonlinear/result.json" ], "nonlinear_mesh_convergence": { "basis": "The two finest matching responses are required.", "name": "nonlinear mesh", "status": "INDETERMINATE" }, "recommended_method": "UNDETERMINED", "report_path": "results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/robustness/ROBUSTNESS.md", "responses": [ { "accepted_increments": 1, "completed_steps": 1, "connector_force_maximum_n": 830.9317772892563, "connector_force_mean_n": 145.43591922238906, "cutback_attempts": 0, "displacement_to_height_ratio": 0.03095691930110754, "equilibrium_status": "PASS", "force_equilibrium_relative_error": 5.673750626047325e-07, "maximum_displacement_mm": 119.92805526918721, "maximum_individual": 1.05711, "maximum_iterations": 1, "mesh_label": "h090", "moment_equilibrium_relative_error": 1.010808624037374e-06, "p99_individual": 0.24769310535714203, "procedure": "combined_linear", "solver_seconds": 22.486566, "status": "PASS", "target_size_mm": 90.0, "total_iterations": 1 }, { "accepted_increments": 1, "completed_steps": 1, "connector_force_maximum_n": 831.9847081263725, "connector_force_mean_n": 144.94551293981647, "cutback_attempts": 0, "displacement_to_height_ratio": 0.031136505535058295, "equilibrium_status": "PASS", "force_equilibrium_relative_error": 4.2251462571843676e-07, "maximum_displacement_mm": 120.62377785002104, "maximum_individual": 1.0721, "maximum_iterations": 1, "mesh_label": "h060", "moment_equilibrium_relative_error": 1.1473706544949826e-06, "p99_individual": 0.24262894736842106, "procedure": "combined_linear", "solver_seconds": 33.776266, "status": "PASS", "target_size_mm": 60.0, "total_iterations": 1 }, { "accepted_increments": 1, "completed_steps": 1, "connector_force_maximum_n": 833.5590100541503, "connector_force_mean_n": 145.00672298587892, "cutback_attempts": 0, "displacement_to_height_ratio": 0.03125307017090152, "equilibrium_status": "PASS", "force_equilibrium_relative_error": 2.637331662694843e-07, "maximum_displacement_mm": 121.07535282600192, "maximum_individual": 1.11023, "maximum_iterations": 1, "mesh_label": "h050", "moment_equilibrium_relative_error": 4.078685473768258e-07, "p99_individual": 0.2412398357142835, "procedure": "combined_linear", "solver_seconds": 58.064649, "status": "PASS", "target_size_mm": 50.0, "total_iterations": 1 } ], "schema_version": 4, "solver_completion": { "basis": "Every matrix cell must finish its expected load steps and pass force/moment equilibrium; Newton iterations and cutbacks are retained explicitly.", "name": "solver completion", "status": "INDETERMINATE" }, "status": "INDETERMINATE" }, "refinement": null, "report_path": "results/cfd_112p5_24mm_y_full/REPORT.md", "reported_static_procedure": "combined_linear", "sampled_stability": { "assessed_wind_factor": 1.3, "checked_wind_factor": 1.5, "endpoint_change_percent": 0.5923128095976823, "maximum_response_change_percent": 1.287729089089482, "meshes": [ { "checkpoints": 7, "label": "h090", "maximum_displacement_mm": 128.88631765662845, "passed_checks": 7, "sha256": "eb9126940b253c5e70d4ea8fdfbf53e4318a99b5f43c6008dc4c27efad00dc13", "source": "native/stability_checkpoints/014d07fd62e1996c8ab74fb28494250270c5f9a218a6e0c63d266ff6fea4f00d/summaries/h090_baseline_mode01_pos000000um__491703959cb5.json" }, { "checkpoints": 7, "label": "h060", "maximum_displacement_mm": 129.65427654479447, "passed_checks": 7, "sha256": "3fb9259d1e3422f737c3236d2ab10d487e3a2c4a700318614b6fb938d5400a72", "source": "native/stability_checkpoints/014d07fd62e1996c8ab74fb28494250270c5f9a218a6e0c63d266ff6fea4f00d/summaries/h060_baseline_mode01_pos000000um__768e6a1e036a.json" } ], "sha256": "1eed8e87344eb011727c7787bf1d0b91ebf72bef32fc4c2c4dfe6b6d8d23502e", "source": "metadata/constraint_tangent_assessment.json", "status": "PASS" }, "schema_version": 9, "solver_qualification": { "buckling_repeatability_relative_spread": 0.0, "buckling_status": "PASS", "connector_formulation": "oriented *COUPLING/*KINEMATIC over clipped shell patch node sets; no *RIGID BODY", "repeatability_relative_tolerance": 0.001, "static_repeatability_relative_spread": 0.0, "static_status": "PASS", "status": "PASS", "threads": 4 }, "static_cases": [ { "displacement_to_height_ratio": 0.03095691930110754, "equilibrium_status": "PASS", "force_equilibrium_relative_error": 5.673750626047325e-07, "material": "plate_bending", "material_status": "FAIL", "maximum_component_utilization": 1.05711, "maximum_displacement_mm": 119.92805526918721, "mesh_label": "h090", "moment_equilibrium_relative_error": 1.010808624037374e-06, "procedure": "combined_linear", "target_size_mm": 90.0 }, { "displacement_to_height_ratio": 0.031136505535058295, "equilibrium_status": "PASS", "force_equilibrium_relative_error": 4.2251462571843676e-07, "material": "plate_bending", "material_status": "FAIL", "maximum_component_utilization": 1.0721, "maximum_displacement_mm": 120.62377785002104, "mesh_label": "h060", "moment_equilibrium_relative_error": 1.1473706544949826e-06, "procedure": "combined_linear", "target_size_mm": 60.0 }, { "displacement_to_height_ratio": 0.03125307017090152, "equilibrium_status": "PASS", "force_equilibrium_relative_error": 2.637331662694843e-07, "material": "plate_bending", "material_status": "FAIL", "maximum_component_utilization": 1.11023, "maximum_displacement_mm": 121.07535282600192, "mesh_label": "h050", "moment_equilibrium_relative_error": 4.078685473768258e-07, "procedure": "combined_linear", "target_size_mm": 50.0 } ], "status": "PASS", "strength_assessment": null, "wind_reassessment": { "accepted_increments": 4, "capacity": { "force_n": 1000.0, "moment_nm": 100.0 }, "cutbacks": 0, "elapsed_seconds": 198.07297674997244, "force_error": 9.11798357364106e-07, "force_max_id": "TV57UI", "maximum_newton_iterations": 2, "mesh": "h060", "moment_error": 1.767810442890215e-06, "moment_max_id": "TV5zSI", "native_run": "native/wind_reassessment/runs/h060_wind1.3__288c3f23eb6d1e03938c/run.json", "numerical_status": "PASS", "policy_sha256": "68fb56a205d008ac79a96d61b06a2d20cbc1735645099d4e9ca36ca4556ae48d", "restart_wind_factor": 1.125, "review": { "displacement_mm": 111.24617802906508, "drawing": "visualizations/wind_reassessment/front_deflection.svg", "equilibrium_status": "PASS", "force_max": 722.901573114757, "force_mean": 127.37437769102473, "force_std": 151.8625640390557, "histograms": "visualizations/wind_reassessment/connector_histograms.svg", "moment_max": 85.0246224397696, "moment_mean": 10.809644033765434, "moment_std": 13.208417549487425, "peak": { "component_id": "C032", "element_tag": 28403, "face": "positive", "node_tag": 31632, "position_m": [ -1.9140000000000001, 0.4371999250791767, 0.771760277943851 ] }, "source": "metadata/wind_reassessment.json", "stress_names": [ "membrane_1", "membrane_2", "bending_1", "bending_2", "panel_shear_12", "rolling_shear_23", "planar_shear_31" ], "stress_ratios": [ 0.52189, 0.4163567415730337, 0.6212330097087378, 0.568443984962406, 0.5936228571428571, 0.7444125, 0.989253 ] }, "source_sha256": "b4b5d8509c5b2722eda23b3aa377310e6ddae51f758012735ac0e5b67d9aae95", "tangent_status": "PASS", "wind_factor": 1.3 } }